GPS vs Car Alarms: Which to Choose?

Photo of author

( — June 3, 2023) —

Car security has come a long way since its inception. Early car security systems were simple mechanical locks, such as steering wheel clubs and tire locks. As technology advanced, electronic alarms and immobilizers became standard features in most automobiles.

However, with the ever-increasing number of thefts, it soon became apparent that traditional car alarms were not enough to deter thieves. Today, there is a wide variety of options available when it comes to car security systems – most notably GPS tracking devices and traditional car alarms. Among these options, Automotive locksmith services can provide additional support.

The decision between using GPS tracking devices or traditional car alarms should be based on individual needs and preferences. This article aims to give a comprehensive comparison of these two popular car security systems and help you decide which one is more suitable for your needs.

All About Traditional Car Alarms

A traditional car alarm is an electronic device that emits loud noises when someone attempts to open your vehicle without the correct key or remote control. Besides making noise, many car alarms also incorporate immobilizers or disable the ignition system.

One significant advantage of a conventional alarm system is that it provides a deterrent effect. Thieves are less likely to target vehicles with an active alarm system because they risk being seen or caught due to the loud siren sounding off.

Pros and Cons of Traditional Car Alarms

  • Pro: They deter thieves from targeting your vehicle due to the loud alarm that goes off.
  • Pro: Relatively cheap and easy to install compared to more advanced security systems.
  • Con: False alarms can occur, causing frustration for you and your neighbors.
  • Con: If a thief manages to disable the alarm without setting it off, they can still steal your vehicle with little or no consequence.

A Guide to GPS Tracking Devices

A GPS tracking device is an electronic system that uses satellite signals to determine the precise location of your vehicle. If someone breaks into your vehicle or carjacks it, you will be able to track its exact location using a mobile phone app or web-based portal. This information can then be shared with law enforcement agencies, increasing the likelihood of recovering your stolen vehicle.

The primary reason for installing a GPS tracker is theft prevention and recovery – but it has other advantages as well. It allows you to monitor driver behavior such as speeding events, hard braking incidents, excessive idling, and fuel consumption. These devices also provide notifications if your vehicle leaves a designated area (geo-fencing).

Pros and Cons of GPS Tracking Devices

  • Pro: Increased chances of recovering your stolen vehicle with precise location data that can be shared with law enforcement agencies.
  • Pro: Allows you to monitor driver behavior for better safety on the road and efficient fuel usage.
  • Con: GPS trackers usually require subscription fees for the service provider offering the tracking system.
  • Con: Risk of privacy invasion, as your location can be monitored by unauthorized individuals if the tracking device is compromised.

The Hybrid Solution: Pairing Traditional Car Alarms with GPS Tracking Devices

One effective solution for securing your vehicle is combining both traditional car alarms and GPS tracking devices. This approach provides maximum security for your vehicle against theft and break-ins. For instance, incorporating a loud siren from a car alarm may deter potential thieves while the GPS tracker helps locate your vehicle in real-time if stolen successfully.

In addition, several modernized systems include a feature called “starter kill,” which disables the engines electrical system until the alarm is deactivated. Combining this feature with a GPS tracker ensures that even if someone manages to bypass or disable the alarm, they will not be able to drive away with your vehicle unnoticed.

Pros and Cons of Hybrid Solutions

  • Pro: Provides maximum security by deterring would-be thieves (traditional alarm) and increasing chances of recovery (GPS tracking).
  • Pro: Allows you to monitor driver behavior and receive alerts for potential issues such as fuel consumption or speeding events.
  • Con: More expensive than installing either system individually
  • Con: Monthly fees may be required for the advanced features and services provided by GPS tracking systems.

In Conclusion: Choosing Your Car Security System

The decision between implementing GPS tracking devices or traditional car alarms ultimately comes down to personal preference, budget constraints, and individual needs. If you can afford it, opting for a hybrid solution that integrates both technologies could provide the best possible security for your vehicle. However, if you are seeking a cost-effective solution and not concerned about tracking your vehicle should it be stolen, then a traditional car alarm may suffice. Either way, making sure that your vehicle is secure from theft is of utmost importance in todays world.