Retail Arbitrage or Online Arbitrage? Which One Is Better?

Photo of author

(Newswire.net — April 20, 2022) — Usually, third-party sellers use different methods to source their products, such as Online Arbitrage or Retail Arbitrage. Online arbitrage has essentially become the modern way to start an Amazon FBA business. It’s slowly overtaking retail arbitrage as many Amazon FBA sellers are deciding to function and operate purely as an online business model, enabling people to run an Online Arbitrage business from anywhere.

But which one is better? Online Arbitrage or Retail Arbitrage? It’s a never-ending debate and a personal preference for which one profits you more. But, according to the sellers involved in this industry, Online Arbitrage appears to be leading the way as more people are showing a keen interest in it. Let us give you an insight into the pros and cons of Amazon FBA Online Arbitrage vs. Retail Arbitrage.

What is Retail Arbitrage?

Retail Arbitrage is a business model in which resellers buy products from traditional brick-and-mortar stores like retailers and outlet stores (such as Walmart, Target, Best buy) at a low price and resell them in another online marketplace like Amazon at a higher price.

Sellers can make a profit from this price difference. This is one of the easiest ways to make money and is popular among Amazon sellers. For example, you may find a discounted product at Walmart for $4 and resell it on Amazon for $20. Reasonable profit, isn’t it?

Is Retail Arbitrage Worth It?

Retail Arbitrage is a great way to get your feet wet selling products on Amazon. Indeed, in many cases, Retail Arbitrage can be profitable. However, there are some factors that you should consider to be successful in your business. Actually, it depends on the price of the products you buy. You will be surprised by facing retail arbitrage sellers who can scale their business and earn up to $10,000 monthly.

In addition, choosing the right strategy can also affect your business. It is essential to determine the product competition level and profitability. Using the Chrome Extensions is very handy for narrowing your product listing.

Is Retail Arbitrage Legal on Amazon? 

This question comes to mind as to whether Amazon permits to do Retail Arbitrage. Unlike what some people believe, Retail Arbitrage is entirely legal on Amazon. There is nothing about it that violates Amazon’s policies. You don’t need to be an authorized seller. Amazon just has some rules for selling products of some categories and brands. You have to be aware of these restrictions.

Pros and Cons of Retail Arbitrage

If a sellers want to get into selling on Amazon with the Retail Arbitrage method, s/he must know its advantages and disadvantages:

Pros:

  • Low cost of entry

The upfront costs are minimal—you source products for your list from other retailers in small quantities.

  • Easy to list products

As you list the products from the items already present on Amazon, it doesn’t require managing to optimize the product listing yourself.

  • Low Risk

By using Retail Arbitrage, you can even start your business by buying just one item. There is no cost of buying bulk inventory from a wholesaler or buying a physical location in this method. These features make this method low-risk.

  • Short-term earnings

You can make money quickly with this method. It doesn’t require building a brand or creating a lasting relationship with a supplier. That’s why Retail Arbitrage is still attractive for Amazon sellers.

Cons:

  • Low margins

You do not get your inventory at favorable prices because of sourcing the products from other retailers. That’s why your overall profit margin reduces.

  • Amazon Restriction

Certain products require Amazon permission for selling. So you should know these gated brands and categories before starting your business.

What is Online Arbitrage?

The act of buying discounted products from online retailers and reselling them with markup prices on another marketplace for a profit is known as Online Arbitrage. Some people call it Online Retail Arbitrage.

Most sellers prefer to resell their products on Amazon, the world’s biggest marketplace. Because manual product searching is hugely time-consuming, sellers use automated product sourcing software like Tactical Arbitrage to look for the right products for their listing.

Is Online Arbitrage Still Profitable?

Although it is getting more competitive, there are still huge opportunities to make money. If you want to manage your business on Amazon and become successful using the Online Arbitrage method, you need to find profitable products and equip the right tools. Avoiding risky products is wise. Besides, consider that you can make a large proportion of your yearly profits in the Q4 period.

Is Online Arbitrage Legal?

This method is legit on Amazon. It is well-known, and over 2 million sellers around the world use it and run their businesses on Amazon. It is vital to avoid counterfeit and follow Amazon policies. However, some areas are grey.

Pros and Cons of Online Arbitrage

For the people who simply need an additional source of revenue, Online Arbitrage is a practical and popular method. But, it would be best if you discover the pros and cons.

Pros:

  • Easy to learn

Without much upfront risk, you can learn how to sell on Amazon.

  • Small money for investment

You require very little money to start. Even $50 could be enough!

  • Saving time

You don’t need to go physically shopping in retail stores for deals.

  • No quantities limitation

To control your risk, you can buy as many or as few products as you want.

Cons:

  • Missing out on the local promotion

As you source your products online, you may miss the offer of physical stores.

  • The difficulty of using automated tools

It is essential to learn how to use this software.

  • Dependency on good leads

Without profitable leads, all of your efforts could be useless.

Online Arbitrage vs Retail Arbitrage

The main benefit of arbitrage is that you should not stick to one specific method. It is possible to use either Online Arbitrage or Retail Arbitrage. Because of its simplicity, sellers mostly prefer the Online Arbitrage method. You can conveniently do it even from the comfort of your own home. So, as you decide to start selling on Amazon, improve your knowledge about both methods and choose online arbitrage or retail arbitrage.

The Similarity Between Retail & Online Arbitrage

Both methods have something in common:

  • The main similarity is that you would require to use software or tools for product searching and analyzing your data. 
  • For both business models, you have to follow Amazon policies and get permission to sell products of gated categories and brands.
  • None of them has the minimum inventory, so managing the number of products based on demands is feasible.

Final Thought

It is possible to sell on Amazon with each Online or Retail Arbitrage method and earn a profit. But sellers need to be informed of the pros and cons of each technique. Because sellers prefer to save time and increased competition, they use special tools to automate their processes.

Choosing a good strategy can help sellers win the “Buy Box” and still find success with Amazon arbitrage.